I guess we're still doing this? Okay...
First of all, I would like to clarify that I have only truly played and hardcored in 5 mobile games - AGG, PAD, VC, and the current two, Love Live! and Otogi, so I don't know how other "balanced games" like Summoner Wars you mentioned turned out. I've come to acknowledge the fact that, in my time of playing AGG, PAD, and VC, the gap between P2W and F2P is huge and we F2P players can barely cover half the distance those who pays in terms of levels, items, and cards. In these games (apart of PAD which doesn't have any working guild system and rankings), in order to get good cards, I've sent countless invitations to various guilds and many top 100 players when I have barely started the game and can barely get a four star, to actually get them. I guess I was fortunate enough to enter a newbie-friendly guild from the get-go in AGG, VC and Otogi who have helped me tremendously in terms of advice, team building, and of course, getting a good card. Some of the whales have, thankfully, accepted my friend request and have helped me while I play the game (however I do remember a few who ranked in events have unfortunately dropped out of playing the game shortly after).
- It's funny that you mentioned "MLB daemons" in your first two statements in an attempt to refute mine. Back when I started AGG and VC (and even still in Otogi), MLB daemons are literally the last thing I've thought of. Heck, my fully five star deck is weak but bearable because I have mostly LB0 daemon. However, I still managed to finished Chapter 5/Level 80 of most events to get that LB0. At least it's something, eh? Then again, back in AGG, there was no MLB system and when one actually get a 5*, it was all good times, even though they were inferior compared to the top daemons of the event(s), and I suppose I still appreciate the fact of getting a 5* from there. I managed to crawl through those days by sheer hardcoring and hoarding like crazy until I'm confident enough, through the help and advice from my guildmates to secure enough good cards, to actually rank for events.
- When you say that it is purely "false hope" for lunch summon, I'd like to say that you're not wrong, but you're not completely right either. I believe everything can be seen in more than one way, so my statement of it being "free mochi and chance of getting something good other than mochi" still stands, and it's always better to have one mochi than no mochi (strictly my opinion). Honestly, looking at the rates, I don't have much hope of getting a 5*, so getting one is actually a surprise to me. I guess I didn't have much hope for it at the end, haha. Speaking about mochis, I don't know about you, but I have NEVER missed any dailies due to events, even if it meant for me to waste an item or two to achieve my final goal. My mochi count has never failed to increase by a minimum of 2 every day.
- Of course, cashiers get bored easily of events because they get to their goal way too fast. I do know that as the game progresses, events get harder, as seen in Thanksgiving, but they did lower it down for Christmas. Again, as mentioned before, I've sent countless friend requests to many whales and little replied, but there are some kind-hearted ones that do. If you're looking for people with good leader cards, it would be better for you to refresh your helper list to get a secondary substitute if you find them whales are rejecting you. For the guild part, I just scan through the guilds in this wiki, and found a newbie-friendly one to join. Doesn't take too much time to wait.
- So far, in this event, I am still in the ranks. Not too high though, so I can't get any MLB daemons. My items are dying away, though. The rates are there to make people cash, so I'm actually not surprised that the ranking this time is harder. Of course, tower events make players use more items than conquest events to get specific stats, so if you would like to think that tower is P2W, I wouldn't blame you, because it does somewhat appear to be so. It is not impossible for a P2W player to rank, though.
- I would like to think of it as Mitama having problems of thinking more events in such a short time that they have long breaks, since they are still new. If you're hoping for new events to come by every week, it could be nice but also very hectic, especially if you want to level up cards since our magatama-levelling system is pretty harsh. If you're hoping for one every fortnight, you can write an email to them. Not much to comment about this one, because any more would need you to contact Mitama themselves about why they are being such.
- I agree that Bond/Reserve proved the gap of F2P and P2W players. However, not all cards have a passive at high LB. I've been seeing lowering in levels of unlocking passives (around LB2) since Perry's event. If I happen to find a whale to crush me in PvP, I would consider myself lucky to find such an opponent, since there's only around 50 whales in the game right now. There are more dolphins (semi-cashers) than whales, and if they happen to be in my level group too to crush me, if Mitama decides to head that way.
I understand that you worry Otogi will progress way too fast before you can build a proper team to pass the events, but I can assure you that no game would be so dumb to the point to hike up a difficulty so quickly before the whales can even overcome it without too much effort in their part. Those who join in late will still be able to catch up, albeit slowly, to a level where they can progress events smoothly. So far, it has been going rather alright.
I see that we have a clash of view between the term "F2P friendly" since we have different experiences in games that we play. However, in my view, Otogi is far more F2P friendly than "parent" AGG that has no free daily jewel summons and no free mochis lying around in dungeons; PAD that doesn't have free daily jewel summons, rankings, exchange and guilds, which forces you to pull summons from jewels you save up for a good card; VC that also doesn't have free daily jewel summons and exchanges and good cards can only be obtained solely from events or you waste your jewels on summons that may not even give you one. If you want it to be more balanced, you can consider sending them a piece of your mind to Mitama for them to consider it. Cheers.